Art by Randy Vargas
Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher
Legendary Creature — Vampire Soldier
Flying Whenever a player sacrifices a permanent, put a +1/+1 counter on Carmen and you gain 1 life. Whenever Carmen attacks, return up to one target permanent card with mana value less than or equal to Carmen's power from your graveyard to the battlefield.
Average Card Type Breakdown
Average Mana Curve
Jump to Section
Most Played With Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher (181)
Sol Ring
89% of decks · $1.38
Arcane Signet
85% of decks · $0.49
Talisman of Hierarchy
61% of decks · $0.57
Orzhov Signet
58% of decks · $0.37
Plaguecrafter
49% of decks · $0.39
Yahenni, Undying Partisan
48% of decks · $0.34
Village Rites
48% of decks · $0.99
Braids, Arisen Nightmare
47% of decks · $4.12
Mind Stone
45% of decks
Deadly Dispute
43% of decks · $0.26
Butcher of Malakir
43% of decks · $0.33
Blade of the Bloodchief
42% of decks · $7.16
Fleshbag Marauder
42% of decks · $0.28
Pitiless Plunderer
42% of decks · $4.99
Cordial Vampire
41% of decks · $2.54
Welcoming Vampire
40% of decks · $3.55
Lightning Greaves
40% of decks · $4.00
Master of Dark Rites
39% of decks · $3.86
Commander's Sphere
38% of decks · $0.34
Damn
38% of decks · $1.84
Path to Exile
38% of decks · $0.64
Bloodghast
38% of decks · $0.92
Selfless Spirit
37% of decks · $0.42
Grave Pact
34% of decks · $30.52
Ashnod's Altar
34% of decks · $16.88
Morbid Opportunist
34% of decks · $0.36
Victimize
33% of decks · $1.34
Black Market Connections
33% of decks · $10.47
Wayfarer's Bauble
32% of decks · $5.61
Dark Ritual
32% of decks · $7.19
Anguished Unmaking
32% of decks · $1.72
Exquisite Blood
31% of decks · $40.38
Twilight Prophet
31% of decks · $3.77
Mavren Fein, Dusk Apostle
31% of decks · $0.34
Smothering Tithe
31% of decks · $56.14
Tragic Arrogance
30% of decks · $0.17
Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff
29% of decks · $9.62
March of the Canonized
28% of decks · $0.31
Redemption Choir
27% of decks · $0.38
Pawn of Ulamog
27% of decks · $0.55
Clavileño, First of the Blessed
27% of decks · $0.72
Skullclamp
27% of decks · $5.21
Vito, Thorn of the Dusk Rose
27% of decks · $10.35
Teysa Karlov
27% of decks · $2.52
Indulgent Aristocrat
27% of decks · $0.32
Phyrexian Arena
26% of decks · $4.26
Warren Soultrader
26% of decks · $20.66
Cathar Commando
25% of decks · $0.22
Flare of Malice
25% of decks · $3.09
Austere Command
24% of decks · $0.37
Sun Titan
23% of decks · $0.35
Sheoldred's Edict
23% of decks · $1.33
Vito, Fanatic of Aclazotz
22% of decks · $0.79
Patron of the Vein
22% of decks · $0.66
Diabolic Intent
21% of decks · $17.18
Reanimate
21% of decks · $10.11
Tarrian's Soulcleaver
21% of decks · $4.05
Liliana, Dreadhorde General
21% of decks · $9.63
Solemn Simulacrum
21% of decks · $0.34
Etchings of the Chosen
21% of decks · $0.34
Buried Alive
21% of decks · $3.61
Sanguine Bond
21% of decks · $7.89
Olivia's Wrath
20% of decks · $0.45
Dictate of Erebos
20% of decks · $17.52
Falkenrath Noble
20% of decks · $0.28
Crossway Troublemakers
20% of decks · $0.32
Sorin, Lord of Innistrad
19% of decks · $0.48
Vampiric Rites
19% of decks · $0.17
Promise of Loyalty
19% of decks · $0.29
Sanctum Seeker
19% of decks · $0.34
Elas il-Kor, Sadistic Pilgrim
19% of decks · $3.81
Phyrexian Altar
18% of decks · $54.36
New Blood
18% of decks · $0.34
Drana, Liberator of Malakir
18% of decks · $0.99
Soul Shatter
18% of decks · $6.14
Zulaport Cutthroat
17% of decks · $1.34
Legion Lieutenant
17% of decks · $0.39
Selfless Savior
17% of decks · $0.40
Amalia Benavides Aguirre
17% of decks · $0.41
Ruthless Lawbringer
17% of decks · $0.24
Utter End
17% of decks · $0.31
Dusk Legion Sergeant
17% of decks · $0.20
Fellwar Stone
17% of decks
Entomb
16% of decks · $18.29
Corrupted Conviction
16% of decks · $0.35
Bastion of Remembrance
16% of decks · $0.30
Umbral Collar Zealot
16% of decks · $0.35
High-Society Hunter
16% of decks · $0.35
Oathsworn Vampire
15% of decks · $0.22
Glass-Cast Heart
15% of decks · $0.37
Pact of the Serpent
15% of decks · $1.05
Generous Gift
15% of decks · $0.92
Champion of Dusk
15% of decks · $0.26
Reassembling Skeleton
14% of decks · $0.33
Despark
14% of decks · $0.32
Grim Haruspex
14% of decks · $2.91
Blasphemous Edict
14% of decks · $4.13
Bloodthirsty Conqueror
14% of decks · $36.39
Dusk Legion Zealot
13% of decks · $0.31
Single Combat
13% of decks · $0.60
Edgar, Charmed Groom
13% of decks
Roaming Throne
13% of decks · $51.97
Marauding Blight-Priest
13% of decks · $0.32
Malakir Rebirth
13% of decks
Esper Sentinel
13% of decks · $58.38
Bolas's Citadel
13% of decks · $16.17
Return to Dust
12% of decks · $0.34
Toxic Deluge
12% of decks · $5.17
Demonic Tutor
12% of decks · $69.17
Promise of Aclazotz
12% of decks
Seal of Cleansing
12% of decks · $0.31
Animate Dead
12% of decks · $7.00
Flare of Fortitude
11% of decks · $4.84
Black Market
11% of decks · $6.40
Teferi's Protection
11% of decks · $46.16
Rite of Oblivion
10% of decks · $0.34
Stroke of Midnight
10% of decks · $0.28
Ripples of Undeath
10% of decks · $8.82
Life Insurance
10% of decks · $0.29
Vampiric Tutor
10% of decks · $54.45
Inkshield
10% of decks · $4.97
Night's Whisper
10% of decks · $6.25
Radiant Destiny
10% of decks · $0.29
Jet Medallion
9% of decks · $14.56
Culling the Weak
9% of decks · $8.04
Barrensteppe Siege
9% of decks · $0.38
Fell the Profane
9% of decks
Wedding Invitation
9% of decks · $0.24
Sign in Blood
9% of decks · $2.74
Kindred Boon
9% of decks · $0.30
The Meathook Massacre
9% of decks · $24.67
Sevinne's Reclamation
8% of decks · $0.39
Bitterblossom
8% of decks · $32.66
Exsanguinate
8% of decks · $0.40
Mortify
8% of decks · $0.19
Tarrian's Journal
8% of decks
Deadly Rollick
8% of decks · $28.68
Fanatical Offering
8% of decks · $1.51
Monologue Tax
8% of decks · $1.10
Revel in Riches
8% of decks · $21.15
Altar of Dementia
7% of decks · $17.25
Obsessive Pursuit
7% of decks · $0.88
The Eternal Wanderer
7% of decks · $2.05
Mithril Coat
7% of decks · $29.34
Expedition Map
7% of decks · $1.44
Sorin, Imperious Bloodlord
7% of decks · $6.47
Heirloom Blade
7% of decks · $0.30
Thought Vessel
7% of decks
Flawless Maneuver
7% of decks · $9.70
Plumb the Forbidden
7% of decks · $0.42
Land Tax
7% of decks · $16.88
Kaya's Ghostform
7% of decks · $1.73
Tithing Blade
6% of decks
Whispersilk Cloak
6% of decks · $2.22
Fracture
6% of decks · $0.34
Martyr's Bond
6% of decks · $0.98
Kaya's Guile
6% of decks · $1.43
Enlightened Tutor
6% of decks · $38.32
By Invitation Only
6% of decks · $0.38
Meathook Massacre II
6% of decks · $2.47
Feast of the Victorious Dead
6% of decks · $0.28
Lotus Petal
6% of decks
Doom Foretold
6% of decks · $0.29
Legion's Landing
6% of decks
Will of the Abzan
6% of decks · $4.47
Get Lost
6% of decks · $3.37
Sejiri Shelter
6% of decks
Blind Obedience
6% of decks · $6.02
The Ozolith
6% of decks · $61.76
Imp's Mischief
6% of decks · $9.14
Dread Return
6% of decks · $0.60
Collector's Vault
6% of decks · $0.61
The Soul Stone
5% of decks · $84.20
Make an Example
5% of decks · $10.43
Feed the Swarm
5% of decks · $0.24
Authority of the Consuls
5% of decks · $5.18
The One Ring
5% of decks · $116.27
Aura of Silence
5% of decks · $9.61
Diabolic Tutor
5% of decks · $2.21
Lively Dirge
5% of decks · $6.10
Trouble in Pairs
5% of decks · $25.56
New Cards
Gleaming Splendor
8% of decks · $30.72
The Queen of Dale
7% of decks · $16.50
My Precious
7% of decks
Bilbo's Gambit
6% of decks · $1.62
Troop of Ponies
6% of decks · $0.33
Creatures (50)
Plaguecrafter
49% of decks · $0.39
Yahenni, Undying Partisan
48% of decks · $0.34
Braids, Arisen Nightmare
47% of decks · $4.12
Butcher of Malakir
43% of decks · $0.33
Fleshbag Marauder
42% of decks · $0.28
Pitiless Plunderer
42% of decks · $4.99
Cordial Vampire
41% of decks · $2.54
Welcoming Vampire
40% of decks · $3.55
Master of Dark Rites
39% of decks · $3.86
Bloodghast
38% of decks · $0.92
Selfless Spirit
37% of decks · $0.42
Morbid Opportunist
34% of decks · $0.36
Twilight Prophet
31% of decks · $3.77
Mavren Fein, Dusk Apostle
31% of decks · $0.34
Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff
29% of decks · $9.62
Redemption Choir
27% of decks · $0.38
Pawn of Ulamog
27% of decks · $0.55
Clavileño, First of the Blessed
27% of decks · $0.72
Vito, Thorn of the Dusk Rose
27% of decks · $10.35
Teysa Karlov
27% of decks · $2.52
Indulgent Aristocrat
27% of decks · $0.32
Warren Soultrader
26% of decks · $20.66
Cathar Commando
25% of decks · $0.22
Sun Titan
23% of decks · $0.35
Vito, Fanatic of Aclazotz
22% of decks · $0.79
Patron of the Vein
22% of decks · $0.66
Solemn Simulacrum
21% of decks · $0.34
Falkenrath Noble
20% of decks · $0.28
Crossway Troublemakers
20% of decks · $0.32
Sanctum Seeker
19% of decks · $0.34
Elas il-Kor, Sadistic Pilgrim
19% of decks · $3.81
Drana, Liberator of Malakir
18% of decks · $0.99
Zulaport Cutthroat
17% of decks · $1.34
Legion Lieutenant
17% of decks · $0.39
Selfless Savior
17% of decks · $0.40
Amalia Benavides Aguirre
17% of decks · $0.41
Ruthless Lawbringer
17% of decks · $0.24
Dusk Legion Sergeant
17% of decks · $0.20
Umbral Collar Zealot
16% of decks · $0.35
High-Society Hunter
16% of decks · $0.35
Oathsworn Vampire
15% of decks · $0.22
Champion of Dusk
15% of decks · $0.26
Reassembling Skeleton
14% of decks · $0.33
Grim Haruspex
14% of decks · $2.91
Bloodthirsty Conqueror
14% of decks · $36.39
Dusk Legion Zealot
13% of decks · $0.31
Edgar, Charmed Groom
13% of decks
Roaming Throne
13% of decks · $51.97
Marauding Blight-Priest
13% of decks · $0.32
Esper Sentinel
13% of decks · $58.38
Instants (33)
Village Rites
48% of decks · $0.99
Deadly Dispute
43% of decks · $0.26
Path to Exile
38% of decks · $0.64
Dark Ritual
32% of decks · $7.19
Anguished Unmaking
32% of decks · $1.72
Flare of Malice
25% of decks · $3.09
Sheoldred's Edict
23% of decks · $1.33
Soul Shatter
18% of decks · $6.14
Utter End
17% of decks · $0.31
Entomb
16% of decks · $18.29
Corrupted Conviction
16% of decks · $0.35
Generous Gift
15% of decks · $0.92
Despark
14% of decks · $0.32
Malakir Rebirth
13% of decks
Return to Dust
12% of decks · $0.34
Flare of Fortitude
11% of decks · $4.84
Teferi's Protection
11% of decks · $46.16
Stroke of Midnight
10% of decks · $0.28
Vampiric Tutor
10% of decks · $54.45
Inkshield
10% of decks · $4.97
Culling the Weak
9% of decks · $8.04
Fell the Profane
9% of decks
Mortify
8% of decks · $0.19
Deadly Rollick
8% of decks · $28.68
Fanatical Offering
8% of decks · $1.51
Flawless Maneuver
7% of decks · $9.70
Plumb the Forbidden
7% of decks · $0.42
Fracture
6% of decks · $0.34
Kaya's Guile
6% of decks · $1.43
Enlightened Tutor
6% of decks · $38.32
Get Lost
6% of decks · $3.37
Sejiri Shelter
6% of decks
Imp's Mischief
6% of decks · $9.14
Sorceries (27)
Damn
38% of decks · $1.84
Victimize
33% of decks · $1.34
Tragic Arrogance
30% of decks · $0.17
Austere Command
24% of decks · $0.37
Diabolic Intent
21% of decks · $17.18
Reanimate
21% of decks · $10.11
Buried Alive
21% of decks · $3.61
Olivia's Wrath
20% of decks · $0.45
Promise of Loyalty
19% of decks · $0.29
New Blood
18% of decks · $0.34
Pact of the Serpent
15% of decks · $1.05
Blasphemous Edict
14% of decks · $4.13
Single Combat
13% of decks · $0.60
Toxic Deluge
12% of decks · $5.17
Demonic Tutor
12% of decks · $69.17
Rite of Oblivion
10% of decks · $0.34
Night's Whisper
10% of decks · $6.25
Sign in Blood
9% of decks · $2.74
Sevinne's Reclamation
8% of decks · $0.39
Exsanguinate
8% of decks · $0.40
By Invitation Only
6% of decks · $0.38
Will of the Abzan
6% of decks · $4.47
Dread Return
6% of decks · $0.60
Make an Example
5% of decks · $10.43
Feed the Swarm
5% of decks · $0.24
Diabolic Tutor
5% of decks · $2.21
Lively Dirge
5% of decks · $6.10
Utility Artifacts (21)
Blade of the Bloodchief
42% of decks · $7.16
Lightning Greaves
40% of decks · $4.00
Ashnod's Altar
34% of decks · $16.88
Wayfarer's Bauble
32% of decks · $5.61
Skullclamp
27% of decks · $5.21
Tarrian's Soulcleaver
21% of decks · $4.05
Phyrexian Altar
18% of decks · $54.36
Glass-Cast Heart
15% of decks · $0.37
Bolas's Citadel
13% of decks · $16.17
Jet Medallion
9% of decks · $14.56
Wedding Invitation
9% of decks · $0.24
Tarrian's Journal
8% of decks
Altar of Dementia
7% of decks · $17.25
Mithril Coat
7% of decks · $29.34
Expedition Map
7% of decks · $1.44
Heirloom Blade
7% of decks · $0.30
Tithing Blade
6% of decks
Whispersilk Cloak
6% of decks · $2.22
The Ozolith
6% of decks · $61.76
Collector's Vault
6% of decks · $0.61
The One Ring
5% of decks · $116.27
Mana Artifacts (10)
Sol Ring
89% of decks · $1.38
Arcane Signet
85% of decks · $0.49
Talisman of Hierarchy
61% of decks · $0.57
Orzhov Signet
58% of decks · $0.37
Mind Stone
45% of decks
Commander's Sphere
38% of decks · $0.34
Fellwar Stone
17% of decks
Thought Vessel
7% of decks
Lotus Petal
6% of decks
The Soul Stone
5% of decks · $84.20
Enchantments (36)
Grave Pact
34% of decks · $30.52
Black Market Connections
33% of decks · $10.47
Exquisite Blood
31% of decks · $40.38
Smothering Tithe
31% of decks · $56.14
March of the Canonized
28% of decks · $0.31
Phyrexian Arena
26% of decks · $4.26
Etchings of the Chosen
21% of decks · $0.34
Sanguine Bond
21% of decks · $7.89
Dictate of Erebos
20% of decks · $17.52
Vampiric Rites
19% of decks · $0.17
Bastion of Remembrance
16% of decks · $0.30
Promise of Aclazotz
12% of decks
Seal of Cleansing
12% of decks · $0.31
Animate Dead
12% of decks · $7.00
Black Market
11% of decks · $6.40
Ripples of Undeath
10% of decks · $8.82
Life Insurance
10% of decks · $0.29
Radiant Destiny
10% of decks · $0.29
Barrensteppe Siege
9% of decks · $0.38
Kindred Boon
9% of decks · $0.30
The Meathook Massacre
9% of decks · $24.67
Bitterblossom
8% of decks · $32.66
Monologue Tax
8% of decks · $1.10
Revel in Riches
8% of decks · $21.15
Obsessive Pursuit
7% of decks · $0.88
Land Tax
7% of decks · $16.88
Kaya's Ghostform
7% of decks · $1.73
Martyr's Bond
6% of decks · $0.98
Meathook Massacre II
6% of decks · $2.47
Feast of the Victorious Dead
6% of decks · $0.28
Doom Foretold
6% of decks · $0.29
Legion's Landing
6% of decks
Blind Obedience
6% of decks · $6.02
Authority of the Consuls
5% of decks · $5.18
Aura of Silence
5% of decks · $9.61
Trouble in Pairs
5% of decks · $25.56
Planeswalkers (4)
Liliana, Dreadhorde General
21% of decks · $9.63
Sorin, Lord of Innistrad
19% of decks · $0.48
The Eternal Wanderer
7% of decks · $2.05
Sorin, Imperious Bloodlord
7% of decks · $6.47
Utility Lands (25)
Bojuka Bog
54% of decks
Vault of the Archangel
47% of decks
Rogue's Passage
47% of decks
Phyrexian Tower
32% of decks
High Market
23% of decks
Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth
19% of decks
Temple of the False God
15% of decks
Windbrisk Heights
15% of decks
Cabal Coffers
13% of decks
Reliquary Tower
12% of decks
Spymaster's Vault
12% of decks
Takenuma, Abandoned Mire
10% of decks
Command Beacon
8% of decks
Midgar, City of Mako
7% of decks
Westvale Abbey
7% of decks
Susur Secundi, Void Altar
7% of decks
Accursed Duneyard
7% of decks
Shizo, Death's Storehouse
7% of decks
Lotus Field
7% of decks
Urza's Saga
7% of decks
Ancient Tomb
6% of decks
Strip Mine
5% of decks
Eiganjo, Seat of the Empire
5% of decks
Castle Locthwain
5% of decks
Volatile Fault
5% of decks
Lands (50)
Swamp
99% of decks
Plains
98% of decks
Command Tower
88% of decks
Isolated Chapel
75% of decks
Tainted Field
60% of decks
Shineshadow Snarl
50% of decks
Godless Shrine
48% of decks
Caves of Koilos
47% of decks
Orzhov Basilica
45% of decks
Path of Ancestry
41% of decks
Temple of Silence
40% of decks
Myriad Landscape
40% of decks
Evolving Wilds
38% of decks
Vault of Champions
35% of decks
Marsh Flats
35% of decks
Shattered Sanctum
32% of decks
Terramorphic Expanse
31% of decks
Fetid Heath
29% of decks
Voldaren Estate
28% of decks
Fabled Passage
25% of decks
Shadowy Backstreet
24% of decks
Secluded Courtyard
23% of decks
Unclaimed Territory
22% of decks
Brightclimb Pathway
19% of decks
Bleachbone Verge
18% of decks
Exotic Orchard
16% of decks
Silent Clearing
16% of decks
Concealed Courtyard
15% of decks
Eclipsed Steppe
15% of decks
Scoured Barrens
14% of decks
Malakir Rebirth
13% of decks
Turbulent Moor
11% of decks
Bloodstained Mire
11% of decks
Obscura Storefront
11% of decks
Witch Enchanter
10% of decks
Polluted Delta
10% of decks
Prismatic Vista
10% of decks
Scrubland
10% of decks
Arid Mesa
10% of decks
Verdant Catacombs
10% of decks
Windswept Heath
10% of decks
Flooded Strand
10% of decks
Fell the Profane
9% of decks
Desolate Mire
9% of decks
Demolition Field
7% of decks
Cavern of Souls
7% of decks
Boggart Trawler
7% of decks
Escape Tunnel
7% of decks
Sunlit Marsh
7% of decks
Sejiri Shelter
6% of decks
Play-rate data via EDHREC. Card images and prices via Scryfall.
Public Decks with Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher
Real decks submitted by their original builders on Moxfield, Archidekt, and other deck sites — click through to credit and see the full list.
Decks built with Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher on Mana Forge (0)
No Mana Forge decks yet — be the first to build and publish one.